Brand Republic

Jobs

 

Directory

 

Are Retailers being forced to revise their business models due to a never seen before "double dynamic"?

Last post 06 May 2009 6:54 PM by Karl Havard. 4 replies.
Sort Posts:
  • 22 Apr 2009 2:41 PM

    Are Retailers being forced to revise their business models due to a never seen before "double dynamic"?

    The UK Retail industry is in the middle of a situation never experienced before. Firstly, we are in the midst of the worst economic crisis or over seventy years. This is bad (Although I did overhear someone in a chip shop saying the "green shoots" are here!), but recessions have happened before and managing costs; sticking to the knitting has seen most retail businesses ride the previous recessions ok. However, when mixed up with the second factor, this tried and tested approach will no longer work. The second major dynamic is how the Internet has evolved (specifically the social web, social media and online conversation) allowing consumers to hold a much higher level of influence and power than ever before. Consumers online, especially in groups are beginning to call the shots and are no longer receptive to "push" marketing approaches, such as advertising.

    So retailers, from the very largest to the smallest, need to reconsider their business models in order to sustain and accelerate growth for when the recession starts to ease. Should they automatically re-open another store? Should they continue with the same distribution channels? or should they look at more innovative and forward thinking measures online? I'd promote exploring the latter.

    Formulating and implementing a brand engagement strategy online, targeted at helping your specific group of consumers needs to be considered. Rather than just focussing on the sale; place a much higher emphasis on providing good and helpful information and truly reflecting your own and employee's personalities, as well as that of your brand. This will become viral, much more personable and you will be in a much better position to create advocates...even if they have never purchased from you.

    This combined dynamic of economic downturn and Internet evolution also means the smaller and medium sized retailers can challenge the bigger players for market share. Smaller retailers can be more agile; reflect their personality easily; and achieve the same level of visibility online as held by the major retailers, or an even higher profile if done well. Change can be executed at a much faster pace as long as the desire is there to do so. This has to come from the very top of the business accompanied by the willingness to take a few calculated risks and "get involved."

    An example of such an organisation is Wallace Sacks and their CEO Stephen Sacks. Stephen presented and took part in the Institute of Leadership & Management's "Delivering in the Downturn" event on 21st April 2009, exclusively for ILM members. Stephen outlined the "nagging feeling" he had had for sometime and came to the realisation that he needed to change the engagement and business model for the benefit of his customers, and for his business. In fact, to put in place a strategy that would allow Wallace Sacks to deal direct and extend their consumer reach. The social web plays a major role in this approach.

    To draw an analogy, the UK retail sector could be seen as a massive, never ending, boat race where everything from cruise ships to inflatable dinghies are taking part. All having the aim of not only staying afloat, but to stay ahead of the competition and take on board more paying passengers as they progress. The combination of the afore mentioned dynamics means the race has reached a tricky part of the course where there are a number of sharp turns to navigate through; in stormy seas, all with ports where paying passengers need to be picked up. The smaller boats, captained well, will find these passengers faster and learn to cater for their needs; the larger ships will find it challenging as it will take longer to "turn" the ship. The vast majority will take it very slowly coming out of it ok, but losing out on the extra passengers. Some will sink.

    Which ship/boat are you on?

  • 28 Apr 2009 11:11 AM

    • IanC
    • Top 200 Contributor
    • Joined on 08 Oct 2008
    • Posts 52

    Re: Are Retailers being forced to revise their business models due to a never seen before "double dynamic"?

    There is another massive issue that will have huge impact on retailers and consumers' 'traditional' retail experiences and inthe process effect whole towns.

    We are entering a period of huge over-supply of retail space and although the consequences are unknown I think it could prove a tipping point for many traditional retail centres and town centres.  The Westfield experience is interesting, they can't fill it with occupants and have been offering all sorts of amazing incentives to retailers to try to fill it.  There is also the impact on other traditional centres such as Kensington High St, so much so the borough offers free parking at wkds (I think). 

    There is currently the equivilant of 6 Bluewater Shopping centres under construction in the UK (in total) yet we are in a time when we probably already have 10-20% more retail outlets than our new austerity will permit.  There is also a point at which, as some sectors go more and more online, there must be a tipping point at which their high street operations can't funtion profitably.

    When this happens I'm not sure how they will manage the move exclusively to online without crashing in the process.  Then when they undertake this move whole centres will become run-down which will further reduce the shopping experience and further speed up the decline of high streets.

    Just my thoughts, but I can't see how there won't be massive carnage as this process takes place?? 

     

  • 28 Apr 2009 11:20 AM

    Re: Are Retailers being forced to revise their business models due to a never seen before "double dynamic"?

    Ian, that is really insightful. It will be very interesting to see how this all shakes out and I agree with you that the high street will become a very different place to what we've all been used to. It would be good to hear the opinions of a major retailer, and whether or not they agree with this; and if so, what they believe the "new" business model should be going forwards.
  • 06 May 2009 6:40 PM

    Re: Are Retailers being forced to revise their business models due to a never seen before "double dynamic"?

    Very well written if a little too long ( sorry but Twitter has me only able to focus on one-liners )

     

    Is what your saying ina nutshell

     

    a) The "recession is almost as bad as the 1930's depression

     

    b) Bricks & mortar are giving way to clicks and mortar as evangelised and prophesised about a decade ago ?

     

    Thanks

    Sean@Ruttledge.com

    Where else ?
  • 06 May 2009 6:54 PM

    Re: Are Retailers being forced to revise their business models due to a never seen before "double dynamic"?

    Twitter can be blamed for a lot of things, especially shortening our attentions spans. Sean, your a) and b) points make up a significant amount of what I was trying to express. However, the slightly more influencing factor is the social web i.e. the consumer now having a much louder and influential voice and there being no recognised business model on how retailers can operate effectively within this "new" environment. Clicks replacing bricks, as of, what now seems, a very long time ago was still a one way brand broadcasting/push marketing approach. The last 18 months has seen that change dramatically...yet even the largest brands can't break the habit! I hope that adds a little more context. Karl
Page 1 of 1 (5 items)