Monday morning we all woke up the news that Kraft Foods had
made a £10bn bid for Cadbury, a bid which Cadbury quickly rejected the offer as
it ‘undervalues the company’. Who says
no to a takeover bid with a 31%
premium on top of share price? – A brand which knows it can get a lot more.
Cadbury is the world’s second largest confectionery company
with a stronghold in Britain and emerging markets which account for over
one-third of the company’s
revenue. Kraft is strong in markets such as Scandinavia
and Brazil, where Cadbury has small presence.
Kraft is looking to use Cadbury’s strong brand presence in
Britain and its positioning in emerging markets to create ‘a global powerhouse in snacks,
confectionery and quick meals’.
I am not suggesting that a strong brand name is all a
business should be about, but Cadbury’s decision to decline the Kraft bid had a
lot to do with the strong brand Cadbury has created through innovative ad
campaigns. We all know building a brand / brand equity requires huge investment
and a long term commitment (not to mention a lot of creativity and market
intelligence) and unfortunately the performance and return are never as easy to
measure as they are with a direct response campaign. In the last couple of
years, Cadbury has grown their brand through brilliantly planned and executed
campaigns such as the ‘Gorilla’
and ‘Trucks’ spots – campaigns
so persuasive we all forgot about the huge Cadbury product recall in
June 2006. This means that, if they were to purchase Cadbury, Kraft would be
able to focus on growing sales in Cadbury’s existing markets rather than their
current conundrum – how to build Kraft’s own brands to be more personal and
meaningful.
Kraft executive Michael Osanloo suggested that Cadbury
was only worth what someone was willing to pay for it – as the world’s second
largest confectionary company with average
12% growth per annum in emerging markets and a strong brand identity
Cadbury doesn’t have to sell. Whether Kraft decides to put in a new (higher)
bid or Hershey’s and Nestlé propose a counter offer, Cadbury is in
the fortunate position of choosing when to sell. Osanloo would perhaps have been closer to the
mark then if he had said that Cadbury is only worth what someone is willing to
pay when (and if) it actually decides to sell.