Brand Republic
 
Edition:
UK |
Asia
 
Digital jobs

Jobs

 

Directory

 

The perfect men's magazine 

Comments:8   Add your comment
With Mike Soutar announcing plans for a free men's weekly magazine there has been a lot of speculation about what kind of magazine it might be and whether it poses a serious challenge to the paid-for men's titles.

We have spent much time around Haymarket talking about it. Craig Smith wrote on his blog yesterday that given that it will be edited by "Phil Hilton, former editor of Nuts, and is expected to compete with the paid-for weeklies, expect the sort of titillation that, when I was entering that age group, could only be found on the top shelf".

The market it is targeting of 18-35 year olds suggests Smith is right. It is the same audience that Nuts and Zoo is aimed at although, if it turns out be acres of flesh with picture captions, it will be a wasted opportunity.

This is because there is an opening with the development of the men’s market to produce something better and more interesting - yes that's right, I am talking about the all-elusive intelligent men's magazine.

What is that exactly? Well, ‘Sport’ offers a glimpse into what this might be. I'm not a terrific sports fan and really have no interest in surfing, sailing, F1 or cricket for that matter, but the magazine has plenty of words with big-name interviews featuring decent pictures spread over three or four pages.

It also has plenty of decent ad pages and has attracted a variety of major brands Mazda, Dolce Gabbana, RBS, Sony Erricsson and Toyota. Today's issue for instance has a BMW cover wrap. These are not bargain basement advertisers.

It points the way for a slightly older intelligent market. We all know Nuts is read by school kids and, if it has many readers over the age of 25, then my guess is that they are mentally challenged…wait that could also describe readers of Maxim as well.

There are other magazines out there doing interesting things and still going strong. Uncut, for instance, but really it is too much about the music and geeky with it too. It always seems to be full of stuff on Bob Dylan. I own a lot of Dylan, but don't really want to read about it.

So what I am suggesting, what I think would work is geeky, but not too geeky, cool, but not too cool. Affordable and not outrageously expensive – I mean I read GQ, but really I know it is aimed at investment bankers.

A mix of music and TV and film, and yes, some sport and fitness as well, fashion, architecture and, yes, some politics and books.

It means also that you don't put some girl in her underwear on the cover every week…actually any week. Women on the front page sure, but in a relevant way. Jessica Alba promoting the Fantastic Four is not a problem (although the Silver Surfer is better – maybe pushing the geek barometer up there), but she doesn't need to be in a bikini does she?

There are other ingredients I'm sure, but what do people want to read? 

Comments

July 20, 2007 9:51 AM
 
I've always thought that "men's" magazines were never really meant for men, but for boys. It was just the way it was labelled to attract the audience. Just as, when growing up, all the girls read "Just Seventeen" - they were all 13 at the time. It makes me sound like an old git (I'm only 29), but now that I have a house, a mortgage, a garden and a bit of disposable income I'd sooner read the features sections of the Sunday newspapers for ideas on holidays and homes, and perhaps a quick once through the back pages for a bit of sports news. It never really occurs to buy one of these men's magazines.
 
 
July 20, 2007 10:08 AM
 
I agree with you about the labelling and like you I read the sunday supplements and like Culture in the Sunday Times, but I also read Total FIlm, GQ, SFX and Uncut. What i would like is some of these magazines - elements of them in once place. I could squeeze it in, compulsive consumer of media that I am.
 
 
July 20, 2007 10:09 AM
 
Making assumptions based on Hilton's time at Nuts is a dangerous thing to do: I would be very surprised if the new mag is anything like Nuts. As for "the all-elusive intelligent men's magazine" - see the new-look FHM out at the end of this month.
 
 
July 20, 2007 10:14 AM
 
Any clues as to what we might be seeing David?
 
 
July 20, 2007 12:36 PM
 
I think you've just described the now-defunct Jack - the A5-sized mag I really enjoyed during it's brief stint on newsagent shelves. It's strapline was simply "an orgy of war, animals, fashion, genius and cool"
 
 
July 20, 2007 3:11 PM
 
I think Jack was pretty good, but there was a boys own element to it. I don't think that's quite it. Close but no cigar - no magazine either for that matter.
 
 
July 23, 2007 11:14 AM
 
This mag can be done and, blowing our own trumpet, we're already doing it online. Looking forward to the new look FHM David.
 
 
July 26, 2007 1:10 PM
 
I got the new FHM yesterday and the style has changed and some of the 'old boys' like Grub Smith are back, but to me all it seemed to be was a lick of paint and not the 'new look' that everybody has been waiting for. I have read FHM since the begining and thought it was great, although over the last few iterations i haven't rushed to shops to buy it..... so when I saw the new one on sale I brought it straight away and was dissapointed to see the same old worn out content in a different wrapper.... all I can say is that I hope they do pull it back, c'mon FHM we know you can do better.....
 
To comment on this post you have to be logged in

About this blog

Gordon's Republic

Brand Republic's daily blog on digital, media and plenty in between.
 

About the author

Gordon Macmillan

Blogging for:

Gordon's Republic

Member since: 03 Jun 2008

Last login: 20 Nov 2009

Total Posts: 1,616

 
 
 
 

Tags

 

Syndication