I have little sympathy for Newcastle United.
It's not that I particularly have anything against the club, but like many I'm bored of being told that Newcastle fans are the most loyal and best in the land. And the club is rivalled only by Tottenham Hotspur for its delusions of grandeur.
Losing its shirt sponsor Northern Rock, the depature of club favourite Kevin Keegan as manager and then being relegated made the 2008/09 season one to forget. News that the club is considering selling the naming rights for St James Park is another blow for the club's fans in my opinion.
In an ideal world few fans would want their sacred ground renamed after a consumer brand, but in some cases fans can accept the club selling naming rights when it makes commercial sense. When Arsenal moved from Highbury it made sense to sell the naming rights to its new ground to Emirates. Firstly, the airline is paying around £100m for the priviledge and secondly, Arsenal's spiritual home was Highbury, not Ashburton Grove.
When it comes to naming rights there appear to be two simple rules. Only bring on a naming rights partner for a new stadium and keep the name short. So, buying the naming right to St James is not a great deal for brand owners and I doubt any will be daft enough to pay the vast sums of money that will justify the decision to Newcastle's fans.
The Friends Provident St Mary's Stadium and The BT Cellnet Riverside Stadium were always destined to fail as branding excercises. Emirates, The O2 and The Ricoh Arena are far better and effective naming rights properties.