Blogs

The FA's ‘Respect' campaign, which discourages footballers from arguing back to the referee, is doomed to failure so long as the man in charge of the country's biggest club fails to control his players.

 

The ‘Respect' campaign is a great idea. Unless a player is superhumanly dim, they will soon learn to keep their mouth shut - or face continual suspension. Simple.

 

But for all the marketing investment by the FA, media attention and endorsement by the game's leading figures the campaign will fail if undermined by its top managers.

 

Fresh from lambasting Premier League head of referees, Keith Hackett for overturning a red card awarded to Chelsea's John Terry last week, which enabled the player to face United, Alex Ferguson watched his players follow each other into the referee's notebook like lemmings falling off a cliff.

 

Match referee Mike Riley - the man who suffered such a torrent of abuse from Chelsea's Ashley Cole last march that the FA's Respect campaign was thrust into the headlines - should be applauded for finally putting his foot down and saying enough is enough.

A manager imposes his will and personality on his team through his choices of players and through what he demands of them on and off the field. This is especially true when a manager has been at a club as long as Sir Alex.

 

Ferguson is far from being the only guilty manager. But he has unparalleled stature and influence - and therefore responsibility.

 

Many footballers should grow up and show some respect to officials, but sometimes so do the men on the touchline who should really know better.

All Comments

  September 22, 2008

What about Dean Ryan at the rugby on Saturday? Seems there were some distinctively football tactics going on in the tunnel....

  September 22, 2008

True. i'd forgotten about that. That was very poor - referees should never EVER talk to managers until after the game.

  September 24, 2008

If significant money were involved in lowering a team's card count then leopards would change spots.

So long as the Rangers Celtic games are exempt - it's part of entertainment value (some refs are known to pray coming down the tunnel)

Won't stop the key problem alluded to in the piece 'Unless a player is superhumanly dim'  Spoilt kids deserve a tough talking to.

  September 24, 2008

Too true.

Brian Clough's teams never spoke back to referees did they?  All comes from the top.

  September 24, 2008

I agree - a fish rots from the head down as they say. Barnet began a self-imposed rule last season of only allowing the captain to speak to the ref like in rugby. It would be good to see The FA adopt this rule. There's nothing worse than watching John Terry ref a match by snarling, swearing and spitting in the ref's face every five minutes.

  September 25, 2008

True, managers need to be hauled into line, but referees need to be tougher.

When I was training to be a ref, my instructor said the way he used to get players under control after a vaguely controversial decision. was this...

Stand on one side of the halfway line and tell them, if you cross this line - you're in the book.  You argue with me - you're in the book.  Do both and you're off.

Seemed to work in non league.

Whether the tough, zero tolerance approach would work with the overpaid prima-donnas who seem to think that no rule or law applies to them (JT parking in a disabled bay - say no more) is a debatable point.

  September 26, 2008

Completely agree Mike. As I say, the ref on this occasion should be applauded. Unfortunately there were a couple of ex-footballers working as pundits over the weekend who criticised him.

To comment on this post you have to be logged in
 

ADVERTISEMENT