Blogs

Devil's Advocate

May 2009 - Posts

Stones and Glass Houses

So snowed under as we are (yes it's still winter in Edinburgh), so wan with care, I got press-ganged yesterday into writing (amateurishly) the Ts & Cs for a website and some eDMs I'm copy-directing. Now, it's a while since I had this dubious pleasure and I'd forgotten quite what rip-off experts are the general public (and a good part of the trade, to boot). These days I usually spend my time thinking about how to make offers work better... not worrying how to stop the massed ranks of Artful Dodgers from picking the pockets of well-intentioned and benevolent promoters. Naturally, I hear the odd horror story on the ISP Board - like 10,000 copies of the same numbered coupon being redeemed through one store - but I kind of shrug them off as maverick events. Then there's those who claim hyperbolically that half of all coupons are misredeemed, and surveys that say a good chunk of the population are quite happy to do it... and some retailers equally happy to oblige them. I understand that to use and accept a coupon without purchasing or selling the product in question is fraud, a criminal offence. The trouble is, it's been made so easy by the system, perhaps its anonymity... in fact, maybe it's the system that's to blame and the 'fraudsters' are just innocent victims of that system........................... sounds familiar; would you buy this argument?

Posted May 21 2009, 08:42 PM by Ian Moore with no comments

Shock horror - human life discovered at Westminster

I can't imagine many people in sales promotion will be surprised by the Telegraph's revelations and allegations of the past few days. For those who spend their working hours thinking about what motivates people, the phrase 'What's in it for me?' springs daily to mind. We know Homo sapiens is an incorrigible and rapacious (hunter) gatherer, and - as the Dawkinses tell us - proved ourselves faster to the draw when it came to cherry picking than our close but soon-to-be extinct cousins. (Otherwise we'd be walking about, monobrowed, looking like Homo erectus..... okay, so we can all think of some who still do.) Thus what else should one expect when a particular echelon of society is exposed to the metaphorical tree hanging heavy and low with ripe fruit? Remarkably, I've heard a few politicians expressing their shock and horror, yet you'd think anyone who spends their time asking for votes on the knocker would be unequivocally familiar with the question I just quoted: "Vote for you? What's in it for me, guv?" Maybe they're not getting out much.

Posted May 14 2009, 08:00 PM by Ian Moore with no comments

What DOES the C in CRM stand for?

If you read my post about a Nationwide cash machine in Scotland trying to flog me the chance to watch the England team train, like me you might also have wondered why they hadn't bothered first to check out whom I support. Chances were - it being Corstorphine High Street - I wasn't an England fan. The bank whose card I used - NatWest - I have been with since around the time of the Hand of God, so they've had ample opportunity to get the lowdown on my interests, and use this info to trigger a personalised message whenever I swing in for a sub. But do they do it? Not likely. What about Vodafone, then - I've had the same mobile number and business account for 19 years (perhaps a British Record?)... do they treat me like a familiar regular each time I call their Helpline? No. I might as well be a complete stranger. Or Sainsbury's... at my local store I've been using these Fast-track gismos since their introduction (10 years ago?) - which means the second I swipe my card they must know I'm back. They ken what I buy, what I like... surely they're ready for me with a basket of perfect offers? No. Nae. Never. Then Boots - only across the car park - and another loyalty card I've had for years. I've just been today, in fact, and they actually printed out some offers with my till receipt. Here they are: £5 off skin treatments, wrinkle decrease, facelift... what?! Oh, my! Never mind that we've reached a stage in technology where every single point of sale could recognise us by the chips we carry in our phones, even the more rudimentary mechanics I've described above are being eschewed - and by some of the UK's best companies, at that. Far from the C in CRM representing Customer (a person, you, me) ... the more graphic word that springs to mind when you think of Gerald Ratner seems far more accurate.

Posted May 06 2009, 02:37 PM by Ian Moore with 1 comment(s)
Page 1 of 1 (3 items)

Search Community

 

About this blog

Devil's Advocate
Ian Moore, founder and Creative Director of award-winning agency Blue-Chip Marketing, and author of Does Your Marketing Sell? is the sector's Devil's Advocate.
Contributors

Ian Moore

Blogging for:

Member since: 03 Jun 2008

Last login: 06 Nov 2009

Total Posts: 127

Recent Posts

Archives

Popular Tags

No tags have been created or used yet.

Syndication

 

ADVERTISEMENT