Blogs

Devil's Advocate

Comments: 7
Rating:
 
From July 7 you won't have to reach for the remote each time there's a commercial break. New regulations published by BCAP (Broadcast Committee of Advertising Practice) rule that ads must be the same volume as their surrounding programmes. Thankfully there's not yet any such thing as SCALP (Spoilsport Committee Against Loud Promotions).

Banning noisy ads is the SP equivalent of being told we can't make pack-flashes stand out. Received wisdom has it that it's our job to violate the pack, wreck the beautifully crafted graphic harmony, disrupt the customer's unblinking trancelike state as they reach for their habitual box of bloggo...

Imagine if all pack-flashes had to conform to SCALP's requirements: brand colours only, same typeface, no moving about of existing design elements, must look part of the imagery as a whole (... wait a minute... this sounds like quite a few briefs I can think of down the years!).  Might as well put the stuff on the back of the pack. Might as well not bother.

I know it's advertising, and the fancy dans deserve all the brickbats that get flung their way, but imagine an industry regulation system where 100 complaints are allowed to wreck a fundamental liberty of the promoter... the person (company) who's paying for the very programmes the protesting pedants sit glued to each evening. It's a sad state of affairs. Let's hope we can keep our heads down and avoid being SCALPed in similar fashion.

All Comments

  May 7, 2008
My Marketing lecturer, within 30 mins of meeting his new class, made a statement that has stayed with me ever since: "Effective Marketing is not about shouting louder than the next guy. Yet many ill-informed Marketers still don't understand this. Shouting louder is the last resort of the creatively stunted."
  May 7, 2008
Nothing turns me off a brand or a TV station (yes, you Sky One and Channel 4) more than having my eardrums battered every time the ads come on. This is one regulation I have no problem with.
  May 7, 2008
I am with Michael here. And like many other Planet Ban-it analogies, such as smoking, there is what you can choose to engage with (or not) and what you get thrust upon you no matter what. Ears do not have mute controls. The whole thing defeated me on a logic basis. If my family's (11 years olds to 86) first reaction is to kill the programme, it seems hard to see how that serves the brand well. But a great visual, and/or awesome v/o, track or jingle in complement... now you're talking.
  July 15, 2008

Date: July 14th

Complaint: They're still doing it!

All it means is that 'the lady' flicks through TV channels more than my tracks through my ipod when it's on shuffle....and our remote isn't very good so there's also a great deal of arm waving involved. Not v.happy.

  December 1, 2008

There's a fundamental difference with pack-flashes.

Viewers set the level of sound they like on their tv, and increasing the average sound level (not one noisy sound, but the average sound of the whole ad) interferes with their choice for the sole purpose of forcefully capturing their attention.

I'd say that not only the ban makes sense, but it actually helps the ad industry avoid the tentation of "shouting" your message, that does more harm than good to your brand.

(But we're still free to feature a scream in the ad, when it makes sense one)

  December 3, 2008

Yeah - I hate the racket too - especially when the mother-in-law's here and the TV's at full blast in the first place.

  April 8, 2009

'avoid loud people, they are a vexation to the spirit'. Extract from the Desiderata. Noisy ads remind me of that Monty Python clip where John Cleese walks into a house with his wife and grabs the hosts *** as he states (shouting) how he is amazed at how big they are.

To comment on this post you have to be logged in

Search Community

 

About this blog

Devil's Advocate
Ian Moore, founder and Creative Director of award-winning agency Blue-Chip Marketing, and author of Does Your Marketing Sell? is the sector's Devil's Advocate.
Contributors

Ian Moore

Blogging for:

Member since: 03 Jun 2008

Last login: 20 Nov 2009

Total Posts: 129

Recent Posts

Archives

Popular Tags

No tags have been created or used yet.

Syndication

 

ADVERTISEMENT