I spend a good deal of my time penning ideas for a major tourist authority. As such, provenance is patently an imperative plank of communication. It baffles me, therefore, when I see a brand bearing strong origins apparently intentionally confusing the consumer over what ought to be one of its strongest attributes.
At this time of the year there is a seasonal bloom of on-pack promotions in the wines and spirits section of the store. There are few market sectors where provenance matters more, so you would imagine that we'd be bombarded with a dazzling array of brand-building offers... not quite what I discovered this weekend, as I battled with one of our two overloaded dodgems-carts around the local Sainsbury's.
Actually the first campaign to catch my eye was a cracker - a jazzily boxed edition of Angostura Bitters announcing the chance to win a trip to Trinidad and Tobago. I almost bought it, even though we have at least a couple in stock (and they seem to last for years!). Where does Angostura come from? Answer: Port of Spain... Trinidad, of course. Excellent.
My faith in promotional marketing was further enhanced by the next one I found: 'Win a Vespa' with Disaronno Amaretto. How Italian is that? Perfetto. (And no knickers in a twist over the imaginary connection between drink-driving and a scooter as a prize.)
Moving swiftly on, things went suddenly downhill when a collar on Black Tower caught my eye. Now, I assume this is a German wine, and - actually - they turn out a pretty reliable product if it's to your taste. Well you'd think the offer would support the brand's origins - surely de rigeur for most wines. Well... unless Limassol has a doppelganger with palms and a blue seascape somewhere up on the Baltic coast...? Last time I looked it was still in Cyprus. Confused? Me too.
Next I discovered that Bombay Sapphire is offering a special deal on weekends in Malmaison hotels - excluding the London branch, which is disappointingly often the case with this kind of promo. While I fully understand the argument about making an offer appeal to a certain target audience, I am nevertheless bemused when a brand with such potentially strong credentials misses a simple opportunity to promote them - and instead supports a relatively unconnected hotel chain. Moreover, I can tell you from experience that these deals get relatively insignificant uptake (which suggests they don't really work). Call me thick, but why not a striking message to win a trip to Bombay, to stay in the same hotel as Queen Victoria (whose image graces the bottle's label)? A bit of simple on-pack branding to reinforce the brand's name and identity.
Finally... and by now we'd shuffled from wines and spirits back to preserves, having forgotten ginger-something-or-other (and reserve supplies of Nutella)... I found a real beaut of a promotion on Capilano Australian honey. Yes - you guessed - Win a trip to New York! Okay - so they're co-promoting with the Bee Movie... but you'd think someone would have spotted the bloomer. Remarkably, the front pack flash actually offers a £4,000 cash alternative, perhaps a Freudian admission that no one anyway would want to visit the Big Apple (at least they didn't cause further confusion by calling it that). Ah well - out of sympathy I bought the honey and it's going down well with the kids.