Blogs

Devil's Advocate

Comments: 0
Rating:
 
I spend a good deal of my time penning ideas for a major tourist authority.  As such, provenance is patently an imperative plank of communication.  It baffles me, therefore, when I see a brand bearing strong origins apparently intentionally confusing the consumer over what ought to be one of its strongest attributes. 

At this time of the year there is a seasonal bloom of on-pack promotions in the wines and spirits section of the store.  There are few market sectors where provenance matters more, so you would imagine that we'd be bombarded with a dazzling array of brand-building offers... not quite what I discovered this weekend, as I battled with one of our two overloaded dodgems-carts around the local Sainsbury's.

Actually the first campaign to catch my eye was a cracker - a jazzily boxed edition of Angostura Bitters announcing the chance to win a trip to Trinidad and Tobago.  I almost bought it, even though we have at least a couple in stock (and they seem to last for years!).  Where does Angostura come from? Answer: Port of Spain... Trinidad, of course.  Excellent.

My faith in promotional marketing was further enhanced by the next one I found: 'Win a Vespa' with Disaronno Amaretto.  How Italian is that?  Perfetto. (And no knickers in a twist over the imaginary connection between drink-driving and a scooter as a prize.)

Moving swiftly on, things went suddenly downhill when a collar on Black Tower caught my eye.  Now, I assume this is a German wine, and - actually - they turn out a pretty reliable product if it's to your taste.  Well you'd think the offer would support the brand's origins - surely de rigeur for most wines.  Well... unless Limassol has a doppelganger with palms and a blue seascape somewhere up on the Baltic coast...?  Last time I looked it was still in Cyprus.  Confused?  Me too.

Next I discovered that Bombay Sapphire is offering a special deal on weekends in Malmaison hotels - excluding the London branch, which is disappointingly often the case with this kind of promo.  While I fully understand the argument about making an offer appeal to a certain target audience, I am nevertheless bemused when a brand with such potentially strong credentials misses a simple opportunity to promote them - and instead supports a relatively unconnected hotel chain.  Moreover, I can tell you from experience that these deals get relatively insignificant uptake (which suggests they don't really work).  Call me thick, but why not a striking message to win a trip to Bombay, to stay in the same hotel as Queen Victoria (whose image graces the bottle's label)?  A bit of simple on-pack branding to reinforce the brand's name and identity.

Finally... and by now we'd shuffled from wines and spirits back to preserves, having forgotten ginger-something-or-other (and reserve supplies of Nutella)... I found a real beaut of a promotion on Capilano Australian honey.  Yes - you guessed - Win a trip to New York!  Okay - so they're co-promoting with the Bee Movie... but you'd think someone would have spotted the bloomer.  Remarkably, the front pack flash actually offers a £4,000 cash alternative, perhaps a Freudian admission that no one anyway would want to visit the Big Apple (at least they didn't cause further confusion by calling it that).  Ah well - out of sympathy I bought the honey and it's going down well with the kids. 

All Comments

No Comments
To comment on this post you have to be logged in
To comment on this post you have to be logged in

Search Community

 

About this blog

Devil's Advocate
Ian Moore, founder and Creative Director of award-winning agency Blue-Chip Marketing, and author of Does Your Marketing Sell? is the sector's Devil's Advocate.
Contributors

Ian Moore

Blogging for:

Member since: 03 Jun 2008

Last login: 26 Nov 2009

Total Posts: 130

Recent Posts

Archives

Popular Tags

No tags have been created or used yet.

Syndication

 

ADVERTISEMENT