I thought Starbucks was getting it together when they launched their MyStarbucks platform http://mystarbucksidea.force.com/apex/ideaHome
The idea is to get ideas from people online, share and vote on them.
So what's going wrong?
1 They launched a large in-your-face campaign about their environmental credentials which ignores the social media rules of advertising: act like a person and be personal. Don't shout. Don't broadcast.
2 Would anyone in their right mind walk into your front room and start shouting about how environmental they are? I walked into Starbucks and saw posters in the shop as well. How about being a bit more humble and a bit more conversational?
3 Before launching your ad campaign, why not test it on MyStarbucks and see what people think first? Let your customers create your advertising with you.
4 I am having second thoughts about MyStarbucks. It is too impersonal. Where are the people behind Starbucks? Who are they? Where's the individual passion for coffee?
5 The founder of Starbucks is meant to be passionate about coffee. How about video-ing him visiting coffee shops in Italy or talking with people in Starbucks? How about podcasting about the environmental work of Starbucks? Get more involved online, share more and create some meaningful content people might actually be interested in.
6 If you consulted with bloggers and people online about Starbucks would they say that what's really missing from Starbucks is a commitment to the environment. I don't think so. The people I know who have gone off Starbucks say it doesn't taste that good any more. That's the crucial point. Focus on the taste of the coffee. Talk about the flavours. Bring the coffee making process to life online.
7 Let's see the real Starbucks online, don't hide behind billboard, shouting ads about how wonderful your green credentials are and be surprised that someone or some thing trips you up.
8 Listen more to what people are saying about you online. Listen a lot more.
9 We all see those community noticeboards in Starbucks but why not create a real community online or use social media to really support local communities in a meaningful way
10 Why not use Mystarbucks to get people to recommend which coffee they like the most when they don't go to Starbucks. Then check out that coffee and see if you could learn from them...
Social media is changing advertising. Advertising needs to be more personal. Advertising needs to be co-created with customers. Mystarbucks is a great idea so put it into practice. Ask mystarbucks visitors to create the next ad, listen to what they say, incentivise them to take part, and I bet the campaign will be a lot more effective than the environmental one which is just back firing.
www.itsopen.co.uk