Recently Brand
Republic reported another pitch that never really was. Well, 3 pitches apparently.
Innocent Drinks seduced various agencies into showing them their knickers no
fewer than 3 times, only to reject them all and revert to doing it for themselves.
Cheaper and more satisfying, I guess.
Last year Soho was spluttering
into its Pinot Grigio about the now infamous and hugely complex British Gas direct
marketing pitch featuring 7 of DM’s finest. Before that, wasn’t there an airline
seeing 13 agencies about a massive er… project?
I mean, don’t you just
love it when you’re told you haven’t won a pitch because, for instance, you’re
too small? But, oh wise client, you knew exactly how big we were well before
the pitch. Why wait till we’ve spent so much time, money and given you all
these ideas? Oh, I get it now.
Enough is enough. What I’d
do is get the AAR to set clients a pitching test, just like the driving test.
If they pass, they get a license that allows them to hold a pitch.
And like the driving
equivalent, they’d get points on their license for pitching without due care
and attention. 3pts for getting more than 4 agencies to pitch; 3pts for giving
insufficient time (less than, say, 3 weeks); 3pts for a stupid pitch list
(agencies so different it’s clear they have no idea what they want); 3pts for
not being allowed to meet the decision maker; 6pts for canning the whole
process once everyone has pitched.
Once a Marketing Director reaches
12 points they’d be banned from running a pitch for 2 years. Break those
conditions and it’s 12 months in Customer Service.